Finding the perfect apartment in Brooklyn? With rental prices soaring and inventory moving fast, renters must be extra cautious. The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, and The Real Deal frequently report on hidden rental issues that leave tenants in costly situations.
That’s why I, Peter Mancini of Pen Realty, a proud member of REBNY & BNYMLS, have put together a must-have checklist to help you avoid rental regrets.
Brooklyn Renter’s Apartment Touring Checklist
1️⃣ Structural & Maintenance Issues
Check walls and ceilings for cracks, water stains, or peeling paint—these could signal leaks or poor maintenance.
Look at the floors. Uneven or sloping floors could be a red flag for structural problems.
Test windows and doors—do they close properly? Drafty windows = high energy bills!
2️⃣ Plumbing & Appliances
Turn on the faucets—Is the water pressure strong?
Flush the toilet—Does it refill properly? Any slow drain issues?
Test kitchen appliances (stove, fridge, outlets) to ensure they work properly before move-in.
3️⃣ Pests & Hidden Damage
Check inside kitchen cabinets, under sinks, and along baseboards for droppings, chew marks, or small holes—signs of pests.
If you see roach traps already in the apartment, that’s a big warning sign!
4️⃣ Noise & Security
Visit at different times of the day to check noise levels. What seems quiet at noon might be loud at night!
Look for security cameras, sturdy locks, and a secure entrance—especially if you’re renting in a high-traffic area.
Walk the neighborhood at night—does it feel safe?
5️⃣ Ask These Key Questions Before Signing the Lease
What’s included in the rent? (Heat, hot water, electricity?)
How are maintenance requests handled? (Is there a super or a management company?)
What’s the lease break policy? (Early termination fees?)
Are there any hidden fees? (Application fees, move-in deposits, or extra charges?)
🚨 Red Flags – When to Walk Away 🚨
❌ Strange smells (mold, gas, musty odors = major problems).
❌ Landlord avoids answering questions or is hesitant to show certain areas of the apartment.
❌ Hidden fees that aren’t disclosed upfront.
❌ Promises of repairs "after you move in"—if it’s not in writing, it won’t happen!
Final Thoughts from Peter Mancini – Pen Realty
An apartment might look great online, but in-person inspections are crucial. Before signing a lease, use this checklist to protect yourself from expensive mistakes.
Final Apartment Touring Checklist (Save This!):
Inspect walls, floors, and windows.
Test plumbing, appliances, and electrical outlets.
Look for pests & hidden maintenance issues.
Check noise levels & lease terms.
Next Up: Lease Agreements – What You Need to Know Before Signing!
Stay tuned for my next blog, where I break down Brooklyn lease agreements so you don’t sign something you regret.
Like, Share & Follow for More Real Estate Tips!
Peter Mancini | Pen Realty | REBNY & BNYMLS Member
#petermancinire #PeterMancini #PenRealty #realestate #referrals #realestateexperts #brooklynrealestateexperts #ASignatureExperience #luxuryliving
📢 Tagging: @wsj @nytimes @TheRealDeal @YouTube
🚀 Looking for a rental or need expert advice? Contact me today!
